Colin Walker, like me, struggles with what should be syndicated to networks and what should be brought back into the blog context. He makes this specific point about replies:
Social replies like on Twitter or Facebook don't, in my opinion, need to be owned - they belong in the context of the social network and that particular conversation.
I suggest reading his entire post so that you get a clearer picture of his struggle.
As you may know I've decided to leave social networking altogether and so I don't have this struggle any more. However, one analogy came to mind when I was reading Colin's post.
When Snapchat arrived on the scene many in the blogosphere thought it was crazy to have such an ephemeral medium sucking up so much oxygen. I didn't see it that way. Perhaps I didn't love Snapchat but I didn't see it as bad simply because you couldn't save what you posted there. It reminded me of going to a local pub. If you drop in at a pub for a pint and rattle off some diatribe about your favorite sports team to the other pub-goers - does that really need to be saved somewhere? If I'm having a random conversation about a movie I saw recently while sitting around a campfire with a friend, does that belong in the Internet Archive?
If we view each site on the web as a real physical place then we begin to realize that some places are museums, some libraries, others local pubs, and still others are rowdy nightclubs. Each have their place to make up the human existence but not all need to be saved or syndicated or shared.
I simply do not view Facebook and LinkedIn and Twitter and Snapchat and Instagram the same as I do my blog. So I do not believe that all of the content that I post here should end up there and vice versa. Some things deserve to disappear. And there is a certain beauty in that. The same way I enjoy a good local pub rant.
Colin's struggle is real - it isn't easy to choose what gets saved and what doesn't. What should go to one network and not another. Especially in the moment it is very difficult to know. And, it is complex for a single person to maintain that connective technology to allow that to happen in the first place.
I don't envy his position. I don't know what I would do if I were him. But, for me, not being on any social media currently has made my decision very easy. What I share here stays here. Everything else you'll never see. And I'm totally cool with that.